Up
through the nineteenth century, western adventurers would occasionally
detain a "native" of some far off land, bundle him on a ship to
Europe and parade him (or her) as some sort of rare creature.
As time passed, treating humans of other races and cultures as
curiosity objects became less politically correct, and the focus
shifted from conquest and capture to display and education. The
Victorian era marked a high in specimen collecting—whether
animal, vegetable, or mineral— and "Mad dogs and Englishmen"
traveled to the ends of the earth to find the unusual and the
bizarre. In this period, Europeans and Americans would re-create
entire villages and bring craftsmen to demonstrate their skills
in expositions, World Fairs, and museum shows. Gilbert and Sullivan's
Mikado, for example, was inspired by such show.
Thus it is the irony of ironies that present day Japan, once an
object of exhibition, has, at present, a dozen or so amusement
parks based around the theme of Europe and North America complete
with "real live" Westerners. Joy Hendry's book on the subject,
The Orient Strikes Back, thus has a rather apropos title.
In Huis Ten Bosch park in Kyushu, one can "travel" to Holland
and see a picture perfect Dutch village, eat Japanized Dutch food,
and buy "European" trinkets. The eponymous park has a full sized
replica of Queen Beatrix's Huis Ten Bosch palace, and is staffed
by 70 or so Dutch, mainly students. In Canada Land in Hokkaido,
the park re-creates the fictional world of Lucy Maude Montgomery's
Anne of Green Gables of Prince Edward Island. The visitor can
"meet" Anne (a red headed actress) and her beau Gilbert, and tour
her house. Parque Espaņa also has a literary theme: giant statues
of Don Quijote and Sancho Panza greet visitors as the pass through
the ticket gates.
What are we to make of this phenomenon? Is the Orient striking
back? Or perhaps these parks are an educational experience? Then
again, the parks may simply be harmless fun. Joy Hendry suggests
that the answer is a mix, and posits the parks are a Japanese
interpretation of unfamiliar foreign and increasing chaotic world.
Like Disney, detail and cleanliness are key, but the ideal of
the park of an almost utopian world draws "repeaters"—visitors
who return again and again. Japanese visitors know that these
parks are sanitized representations of European and American culture,
in the same way that visitors know that Disney's animatronic display
"It's a Small World" is not an accurate depiction of global geo-political
relations. Hendry interviews a number of Japanese visitors at
the park, and the majority state that the parks were not so much
an educational experience but "just fun." Like Japanese gardens
and landscaping—which are interpretations of nature and
all its beautiful and terrible complexities— Hendry argues
that the parks provide spiritual as well as material nourishment
in an increasingly complex world.
The book is an academic ethnography that happens to be lively
and peppered with good humor. The book takes some effort, but
Hendry assumes no previous knowledge. In the first few chapters,
she sets up the interpretations as well as the history of theme
parks around the world. An entire chapter is devoted to Disney,
both in Japan and abroad. Such discussions of post-modern theory
behind theme parks could become weighty, but Hendry walks a fine
line by keeping the tone light. She never takes herself too seriously
,and while she is respectful of heavy-handed academics who extemporize,
for example, on the "gradient of cultural flow" in Disney's Jungle
Cruise, her writing is detached enough to lend the air of the
faintly ridiculous.
Hendry does not lose her sense of whimsy, and she clearly likes
her subject matter: the topic after all is amusement parks. She
then describes various theme parks, including non-Western theme
parks, in varying levels of detail. She guides the reader through
her own personal commentary and observations. This approach works
for the topic as the reader encounters the park as a visitor:
we feel the authors first impressions, and Hendry literary wonders
through the park taking the reader along.
Her discoveries and experiences become ours. Other visitors impressions
of the park are presented informally: we can practically hear
Hendry striking up conversation with visitors striking up small
talk. She takes us behind the scenes of the park to meet the modern
day human exhibitions. By the end of the book, Hendry develops
a multi-layered analysis of cultural "wrapping"; a complex idea,
but one she gently guides the reader though.
If there are weaknesses to the book, it would be that her style
makes it difficult to find factual information on the park. It
is all buried in the text along with her impressions. The book
is badly in need of an appendix: a list of parks she visited,
maps, park sizes, financial information, and visitor statistics
would have been useful. Although she briefly addresses the issue,
a more systematic analysis of theme park popularity is warranted.
Within these parks, the world is a harmonious place in which cultural
barriers are taken down. Leisure and fun are the theme and the
nations of the world are at peace. Tacky? Kitsch? Perhaps. But
harmless fun, posits Henry—it's a small world after all.
